CPAC Meeting Archive

Meeting Materials

PowerPoint Presentations

• Sunshine Law/Robert’s Rules of Order/Ethics

Audio (Video unavailable)

Meeting Materials

• Proposed Rules of Practice and Procedure for South Maui CPAC

Draft South Maui Community Plan

• Section 1 | Plan Framework

PowerPoint Presentations

• Planning Department Staff Presentation

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman – Proposed Amendments

Meeting Materials

PowerPoint Presentations

• Planning Department Staff Presentation – Plan Framework

Draft South Maui Community Plan

• Section 1 | Plan Framework

Proposed map replacements (Draft Plan pg. 3)

• Moku
• Moku District Boundaries
• Moku with District Boundaries (Alternate colors)
• Moku with District Boundaries

Proposed map replacements (Draft Plan pg. 9)

• Ahupua’a
• Ahupua’a District Boundaries
• Ahupua’a with District Boundaries
• Ahupua’a with District Boundaries (Alternate colors)

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Section 1
• Everett Dowling_Section 1
• Daniel Kanahele_Section 1

Testimony

• David Goode_Section 1

Meeting Materials

PowerPoint Presentations

• Planning Department – Understanding Policies and Actions
• Maui County Department of Transportation
• State Department of Transportation

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network

• Policies | Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman – North-South Collector Road GIS

Testimony

• Bud Pikrone_Goal 2.1

Received after testimony deadline

• Larry Stevens_Goal 2.1

Meeting Materials

PowerPoint Presentations

• Maui County Arborist
• Maui County Department of Parks and Recreation

Goal 2.2 | Safe, Healthy, Livable Communities for All

• Policies | Actions
• Department Suggested Policy Edits

Section 2 Goals

• Goal 2.1 | A complete, balanced, and connected transportation network
• Goal 2.2 | Safe, healthy, livable communities for all
• Goal 2.3 | Ready and resilient systems
• Goal 2.4 | Mauka to makai watershed management
• Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Goals
• Lehuanani Huddleston-Hafoka_2.2 Policies

Testimony

• Pat Grant
• Randy Wagner
• Thomas Croly

Received at meeting

• Elaine Malina (Maui Green & Beautiful) _Goal 2.2
• Adele Rug_Maui County Planting Plan

Received after testimony deadline

• Larry Stevens_Goal 2.2

Meeting Materials

PowerPoint Presentations

• Transient Accommodations in South Maui
• Department of Housing and Human Concerns
• Missing Middle Housing

Goal 2.2 | Safe, Healthy, Livable Communities for All

• Actions
• Department Suggested Policy Edits

Section 2 Goals

• Goal 2.1 | A complete, balanced, and connected transportation network
• Goal 2.2 | Safe, healthy, livable communities for all
• Goal 2.3 | Ready and resilient systems
• Goal 2.4 | Mauka to makai watershed management
• Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Background on CIP distribution vs population distribution in Maui County
• Rob Weltman_Expanding the coastal access study
• Rob Weltman_Fund South Maui – Coastal Access Report
• Rob Weltman_ Item to add to the SMCP 2.2 actions
• Rob Weltman_11.10-CPAC-Draft-Section-2-2
• Rob Weltman_11.10-CPAC-Draft-Section-4-2
• Rob Weltman_Proposed and past goals
• Rob Weltman_What are the actions around housing in the SCMP, WMCP, KMCP
• Rob Weltman_What are the policies around housing in the SCMP, WMCP, KMCP

Testimony

• Dave Goode_Goal 2.2
• Stan Franco_Goal 2.2

Received at meeting

• House Maui

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.2 | Safe, Healthy, Livable Communities for All

• Policies | Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_11.10-CPAC-Draft-Section-2-2
• Rob Weltman_11.10-CPAC-Draft-Section-4-2
• Rob Weltman_ Item to add to the SMCP 2.2 actions
• Rob Weltman_What are the actions around housing in the SCMP, WMCP, KMCP
• Rob Weltman_What are the policies around housing in the SCMP, WMCP, KMCP

Testimony

• Kate Blystone (House Maui)_Goal 2.2
• Brandi Corpuz_Goal 2.2

Received at meeting

• Rory Frampton_Goal 2.2
• Dean Frampton_Goal 2.2

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.2 | Safe, Healthy, Livable Communities for All

• Actions

Section 2 Goals

• Goal 2.1 | A complete, balanced, and connected transportation network
• Goal 2.2 | Safe, healthy, livable communities for all
• Goal 2.3 | Ready and resilient systems
• Goal 2.4 | Mauka to makai watershed management
• Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

CPAC Member Input

• Daniel Kanahele _ Actions 2.08-2.14
• Member Input_Rob Weltman for 12_14_22_Goals
• Member Input_Rob Weltman for Goal 2.2 section 4

Testimony

• Will Wilkinson_Goal 2.2
• Karen Lewis_Goal 2.2
• Mark Hyde: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 (Goals 2.1 and 2.2)

Received at meeting

• Elizabeth Voight
• Steve Mark_Goal 2.1

Received after testimony deadline

• Patricia and David Johnson_Goal 2.2

Meeting Materials

PowerPoint Presentations

• Kaleikoa Ka’eo

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced, and Connected Transportation Network

• Policies | Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.1 Policies
• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.1 Actions.pdf

Testimony

• Mark Hyde_Goal 2.1.pdf

Received after testimony deadline

• Brandi Corpuz_Goal 2.1
• Lynn Britton_Goal 2.1

Meeting Materials

PowerPoint Presentations

• Coastal Resilience and Disaster Preparedness – Maui County Planning Department

Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network

• Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Additional Actions for Goal 2.1
• Rob Weltman_2.1-Actions_-Planning-Department-Draft-SMCP

Testimony

• Mark Hyde_Goal 2.1
• Brandi Corpuz_Goal 2.1

Received after testimony deadline

• Cal Chipcase_Goal 2.3

*All materials below were posted prior to the meeting’s cancellation.*

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network

• Actions

Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems

• Policies | Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Daniel Kanahele_Proposed Revisions to Goal 2.1
• Vernon Kalanikau_Goal 2.3

Testimony

• Mark Deakos_Goal 2.3
• Mark Deakos_Goal 2.3 (National Marine Fisheries Letter)
• Lynn Britton (Ma’alaea Village Association)_Goal 2.1
• Ma’alaea Village Association_Goal 2.3

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems

• Policies | Actions

Presentations

• Department of Water Supply
• Department of Environmental Management – Wastewater Division

CPAC Member Input

• Vernon Kalanikau_Goal 2.3

Testimony

• Mark Deakos_Goal 2.3
• Mark Deakos_Goal 2.3 (National Marine Fisheries Letter)
• Ma’alaea Village Association_Goal 2.3

Received after testimony deadline

• Mark_Deakos Goal 2.3 (Study: Long lasting impacts of beach renourishment)

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Policies | Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltmen_Goal-2.4_Policies_Draft-SMCP_Jan-25
• Rob Weltman_Goal-2.4_Actions_Draft-SMCP_Jan.-25
• Lehuanani Huddleston-Hafoka_Goal 2.4

Testimony

• 1_Maalaea Village Association_Goal 2.4
• 2_Maalaea Village Association_Goal 2.4
• Mark Deakos_Goal 2.4
• Michael Reyes_Goal 2.4

Received at meeting

• Robin Knox_Goal 2.4

Meeting Materials

*NOTE: This meeting also references CPAC member input and testimony from the January 25 recessed meeting.*

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Policies | Actions

Gulch Maps

• North Kihei gulches with 100ft buffer
• Kihei gulches with 100ft buffer
• Maui Meadows area gulches with 100ft buffer
• Makena gulches with 100ft buffer

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman Goal 2.4 Policies
• Tova Callender_Goal 2.4

Testimony

• Lucienne deNaie #1 Goal 2.4
• Lucienne deNaie #2 Goal-2.4
• Dave Goode_Goal 2.4

Received at meeting

• Dean Frampton_Goal 2.4

Received after testimony deadline

• Robin Knox_Goal 2.4 (Updated comments to testimony submitted for January 25 meeting)
• Robin Knox_Email
• Robin-Knox_Goal_2.4_email_link

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

• Policies | Actions

Updated Department Recommended

• Revised Policies | Revised Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Daniel Kanahele_Goal 2.5
• Daniel-Kanahele_Goal-2.5_Doc.2
• Lehuanani Huddleston-Hafoka_Goal 2.5 Policies

Testimony

Received at meeting

• Lucienne DeNaie_Goal 2.5
• Lucienne DeNaie_SMCP Preservation areas
• Kelly King_Goal 2.5
• Claire Apana_Goal 2.5

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Policies (as revised by CPAC)
• Actions

PowerPoint Presentations

• Daniel Halsey – United Designers

Drainageway Maps

• Drainageways_Figure 3.17
• Drainageways (protected and excluded)

Identified drainageway maps

• North Kīhei
• Kīhei
• Maui Meadows
• Makena

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_DRAFT CPAC Schedule
• Rob Weltman_Policy item 2.4.5 concerns
• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.4 Actions
• Tova Callender_Policy 2.4.5 (Email)

Testimony

• David Dorn_Goal 2.4
• Lucienne DeNaie_Goal 2.4
• Aja Eyre_Maui Tomorrow_Goal 2.4

Received at meeting

• Robin Knox_Goal 2.4 Policies
• Robin Knox_Goal 2.4 Actions

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Policies (as revised by CPAC)
• Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.4 Actions
• Rob Weltman_Stormwater-mitigation-mauka-of-Kihei

Testimony

Received after testimony deadline

• David Dorn_Goal 2.4
• Dean Frampton_Goal 2.4

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Actions (4.13 – 4.17)

Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

• Policies (as revised by CPAC)
• Actions (Department Recommended)

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.4 Actions
• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.5 Actions

Testimony

• Brandi-Corpuz_Goal-2.4
• Charlene Schulenburg_Goal 2.4
• David Dorn_Goal 2.4
• David Dorn_Goal 2.5
• Ma’alaea Village Association_Goal.2.5
• Johann Lall_Goal 2.5

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems

• Policies (2.3.16 – 2.3.19)
• Actions

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Actions (4.13 – 4.17)

Other Committee Business

• 3.7.23 Draft CPAC Schedule
• CPAC Letter to Council – Request for Extension

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.3 Policies (annotated)
• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.3 Actions (annotated)
• Rob Weltman_Cess pools in South Maui
• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.4 Actions (annotated)

Testimony

• Natalie Harcrow_Goal 2.3

Received at meeting

• Casey Lamb_Goal 2.3

Received after testimony deadline

• David Dorn_Goals 2.3 and 2.4
• David Dorn_Goals 2.3 and 2.4 (additional testimony)

Meeting Materials

*NOTE: This meeting also references CPAC member input and testimony from the March 8 recessed meeting.*

Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems

• Policies (2.3.16 – 2.3.19)
• Actions

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Actions (4.13 – 4.17)

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.3 Actions (annotated) (UPDATED from 3/8 meeting)
• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.4_Acquiring wetland properties in Kihei

Testimony

• Natalie Harcrow_Goal 2.3 (UPDATED from 3/8 meeting)
• David Dorn_Goals 2.3 and 2.4
• David Dorn_Goals 2.3 and 2.4 (2)
• David Dorn_Goal 2.4
• Brandi Corpuz_Goal 2.4
• Kelly King_Goal 2.4
• Charlene Schulenburg_Goal 2.4
• Robin Knox_Goal 2.4

Received after testimony deadline

• David Dorn et al._Goal 2.4
• Robin Knox_Goal 2.4 (Email)

Meeting Materials

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network

• Actions

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.1 Actions (annotated)
• Rob Weltman_Proposed Action 2.1.03
• Mike Moran_Proposed Language 2.1.11
• Daniel Kanahele_Proposed Revisions to Goal 2.1

Testimony

• Dick Mayer_Goal 2.1
• Natalie Harcrow_Goal 2.1

Meeting Materials

To be reviewed by CPAC

• Goal 2.1 Actions (1.12 – 1.17)

Policies and Actions approved by CPAC

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.2 | Safe, Healthy, Livable Communities for All

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

• Policies | Actions

Policy and Action Edits (Tracked Changes)

• Goal 2.1 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.1 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.2 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.2 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.3 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.3 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.4 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.4 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.5 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.5 Actions (Edits)

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.1 | Actions 1.12-1.17 (annotated)
• Rob Weltman_Goal 2.1 | Action 1.13 (Mauka Bypass)
• Rob Weltman_ALL Policies and Actions (annotated)
• Rob Weltman_Policy 2.2.28 (Prime farmland within SMCP district)
• Everett Dowling_Policy Suggestions

Testimony

• Natalie Harcrow_Goal 2.1

Received after testimony deadline

• Randy Wagner_Goal 2.1

Meeting Materials

Policies and Actions approved by CPAC

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network

• Policies* | Actions*

*Updated as of 3/29 CPAC meeting

Goal 2.2 | Safe, Healthy, Livable Communities for All

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

• Policies | Actions

Policy and Action Edits (Tracked Changes)

• Goal 2.1 Policies (Edits)*
• Goal 2.1 Actions (Edits)_Updated as of 3/29 CPAC meeting
• Goal 2.2 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.2 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.3 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.3 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.4 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.4 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.5 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.5 Actions (Edits)

PowerPoint Presentation

• Planning Department – Plan Implementation Division

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_ALL Policies and Actions (annotated – updated 4/4/23)

Testimony

• Randy Wagner_Goal 2.1
• Albert Perez_Goal 2.1

Received at meeting

• Lucienne De Naie_Goal 2.1

Meeting Materials

*NOTE: This meeting also references CPAC member input and testimony from the April 5 recessed meeting.*

Policies and Actions approved by CPAC

Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network

• Policies* | Actions*

*Updated as of 3/29 CPAC meeting

Goal 2.2 | Safe, Healthy, Livable Communities for All

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management

• Policies | Actions

Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

• Policies | Actions

Policy and Action Edits (Tracked Changes)

• Goal 2.1 Policies (Edits)*
• Goal 2.1 Actions (Edits)_Updated as of 3/29 CPAC meeting
• Goal 2.2 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.2 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.3 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.3 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.4 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.4 Actions (Edits)
• Goal 2.5 Policies (Edits)
• Goal 2.5 Actions (Edits)

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_ALL Policies and Actions (annotated) – updated 4/10/23
• Daniel Kanahele_Goals 2.3-2.5

Testimony

• Albert Perez_Goal 2.1
• Kelly Takaya King_Observations of 4/5 CPAC Meeting

Received at meeting

• David Goode_Goal 2.4

Meeting Materials

Draft South Maui Community Plan

• Section 3 – Growth Framework
• South Maui Community Plan Maps (Updated April 2023)
• Planning Department Presentation: Land Use Processes Overview

Housing Development Forum

• Haleakala Ranch and Ka’ono’ulu Ranch_Submittal Letter
• Haleakala Ranch and Ka’ono’ulu Ranch_Presentation
• Maui Research & Technology Park_Presentation
• Department of Hawaiian Home Lands_Presentation
• Wailea Golf_Presentation
• Ledcor Maui_Presentation

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Housing Development Forum

Testimony

• Lynn Britton (MVA)_Māʻalaea Subarea
• Charlene Schulenburg_Section 3
• Kirk Horiuchi_North Kihei Subarea
• Christian Chang_Wailea-Mākena Subarea
• Albert Perez_Housing Development Forum

Received at meeting

• Dean Frampton_Section 3

Received after testimony deadline

• Brett Gobar_Miscellaneous

Meeting Materials

Draft South Maui Community Plan

• Section 3 – Growth Framework
• South Maui Community Plan Maps (Updated April 2023)
• Subarea 1 Map | Mā‘alaea/Keālia
• Mā‘alaea Detail Map

PowerPoint Presentations

• Department of Planning Long Range Division – Community Plan Designations
• Community Plan Designations Game

Other Committee Business

• Resolution No. 23-122, FD1_Approving a Time Extension for the South Maui Community Plan Advisory Committee

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Mā‘alaea in the Community Plans
• Rob Weltman_Proposed SMCP Designations and Associated Zoning Designations (Mā‘alaea/Keālia subarea)
• Rob Weltman_Guidelines for the New Community Plan Land Use Designations

Testimony

• Lynn Britton_Subarea 1 (Mā‘alaea/Keālia)
• Albert Perez (Maui Tomorrow)_Community Plan Designations

Meeting Materials

*NOTE: This meeting also references CPAC member input and testimony from the May 3 recessed meeting.*

Draft South Maui Community Plan

• Community Plan Designations
• Community Plan Designations and Zoning Districts
• Subarea 2 Map | North Kīhei
• Areas of Change | North Kīhei
• CPAC-Approved Changes for Subarea 1 | Mā‘alaea/Keālia

NEW Materials for 5/10 Meeting

• Areas of Change | North Kīhei **UPDATED as of 5/4/23**
• Areas of Change | Māʻalaea

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_UPDATED Guidelines for the New Community Plan Land Use Designations
• Rob Weltman_New businesses coming to Māʻalaea
• Rob Weltman Subarea 2: North Kihei
• Rob Weltman_Community Plan Designations_Location of land uses

Testimony

• Calvert Chipcase_Community Plan Designations
• Lahela Aiwohi_Community Plan Designations
• Albert Perez_Community Plan Designations, Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)

Meeting Materials

*NOTE: This meeting also references CPAC member input and testimony from the May 3 and May 10 recessed meetings.*

Draft South Maui Community Plan

• Community Plan Designations
• Community Plan Designations and Zoning Districts
• Subarea 2 Map | North Kīhei
• Areas of Change | North Kīhei
• CPAC-Approved Changes for Subarea 1 | Mā‘alaea/Keālia

NEW Materials

• Planning Department Letter to CPAC_Community Plan Designations

Materials from 5/10 Meeting

• Areas of Change | North Kīhei **UPDATED as of 5/4/23**
• Areas of Change | Māʻalaea

Testimony

• Robert Stoner_Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)
• Maui Tomorrow_Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)

Received after testimony deadline

• Dick Mayer_Community Plan Designations

Meeting Materials

Draft South Maui Community Plan

• Subarea 3: South Kīhei
• Areas of Change: Central Kīhei, County-Owned Parcel
• Subarea 4: Wailea
• Area of Change: Honua’ula
• South Maui: Mixed Use Images

CPAC Member Input

• Rob-Weltman_Subarea-3_South Kiheī-proposed-changes-in-land-use
• Rob-Weltman_Subarea-4-Wailea-proposed-changes-in-land-use

Testimony

• Ryan Churchill_Subarea 3_South Kīhei
• Rory Frampton_Subarea 3_South Kīhei
• Justin Parsons_Subarea 4_Wailea
• Jeffrey Ueoka_Subarea 4_Wailea

Received at meeting

• Dean Frampton_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Maui Tomorrow_Subarea 3 (South Kīhei)

Meeting Materials

• Areas of Change | Mauka North Kīhei (Updated to reflect CPAC designations) _{^{– Updated as of 5/26/23}}
• CPAC Draft Map | North Kīhei
• Subarea 4 | Wailea
• Areas of Change | Honua’ula
• Subarea 5 | Mākena
• Areas of Change | Mākena
• Subarea 6 | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio
• Areas of Stability | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Remaining land use issues in Subareas 2 and 4
• Rob Weltman_Why will Polo Beach be Resort
• Rob Weltman_Proposed land use changes in Subareas 5-6

Testimony

• Lucienne de Naie_Subarea 4 | Wailea
• Teena Rasmussen_Subarea 2 | North Kīhei
• Kate Blystone (HouseMaui)_Subarea 2 | North Kīhei
• Jeff Gilbreath_Subarea 2 | North Kīhei
• Rory Frampton_Subarea 2 | North Kīhei

Dean Frampton_Subareas 4 and 5 | Wailea and Mākena

• Dean Frampton_Testimony
• Dean Frampton_Exhibit A_Honua’ula Maui County Ordinance No. 3553 (marked)
• Dean Frampton_Exhibit B_Honua’ula Maui County Ordinance No. 4845
• Dean Frampton_Exhibit C_Honua’ula Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Decision and Order
• Dean Frampton_Exhibit D_Honua’ula Partners Draft Map

Meeting Materials

Draft South Maui Community Plan

• Subarea 4 | Wailea
• Subarea 5 | Mākena
• Areas of Change | Mākena
• Subarea 6 | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio
• Areas of Stability | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

Department Recommended Maps

• Updated Draft Map | Wailea
• Draft Map | Mākena
• Draft Map | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Proposed land use changes in Subareas 5 and 6

Testimony

• Johann Lall_Subarea 5 (Mākena)

Received at meeting

• Ane Takaha_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Brandi Corpuz_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Laura Greenwood_Subarea 4 (Wailea)

Maui Tomorrow_Subareas 4 (Wailea) and 5 (Mākena)

• Maui Tomorrow_Testimony
• Maui Tomorrow_Mākena Settlement Community Benefits for CPAC
• Maui Tomorrow_Mākena signed settlement agreement
• Maui Tomorrow_Settlement Agreement Exhibit A
• Maui Tomorrow_Settlement Agreement Exhibit A1
• Maui Tomorrow_Settlement Agreement Exhibit A2
• Maui Tomorrow_Settlement Agreement Exhibit B
• Maui Tomorrow_Settlement Agreement Exhibit C
• Maui Tomorrow_Settlement Agreement Exhibit D

Received after testimony deadline

• Buck Joiner_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Dechen (Mary) Groode_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Susan Douglas_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Bill and Bobbie Best_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Vika FittsMilgrim_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Jeanne Schaaf and Robert Werner_Subarea 4 (Wailea)

Meeting Materials

Honua’ula/Wailea 670 Land Use Designations

• Updated Department Recommended Map | Wailea
• Areas of Change | Honua’ula

Review of Adopted Land Use Designations

• CPAC Recommended Land Use Designations (as of 6/15/23)

Text of Section 3.3-3.5

• Section 3.3 | Community Plan Map and Subareas(Text Only)
• Section 3.4 | Areas of Change (Text Only)
• Section 3.5 | Areas of Stability (Text Only)

Additional Materials

• Parcels affected by 3.2 SLR-XA
• Requested Input from Ka’onohi Lee_Section 3.3 Text

CPAC Member Input

• Tova Callender_SLR-XA Parcels for Open Space
• Rob Weltman_Proposed SLR-XA Parcels for Open Space
• Rob Weltman_Interactive Map of Proposed SLR-XA Parcels for Open Space

Testimony

• Dean Frampton_Honua’ula/Wailea 670
• Albert Perez_Honua’ula/Wailea 670
• Robin Knox_Other Committee Business
• Ann Wallace_Other Committee Business
• Robert Werner_Other Committee Business
• Sandra Morey_Other Committee Business
• Sarah Biggs_Other Committee Business
• Eva Roberts_Other Committee Business
• Kelly Takaya King_Other Committee Business

Received after testimony deadline

• Dean Frampton_Honua’ula/Wailea 670
• Tanya Gabriel_Other Committee Business

*All materials below were posted prior to the meeting’s cancellation.*

Meeting Materials

Honua’ula/Wailea 670 Growth Alternatives/Maps

• Original Department Recommended Map (August 2022)
• Updated Map (July 2023)

Review of Growth Alternatives/Maps

Subarea 1 | Mā‘alaea/Keālia

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 2 | North Kīhei

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 3 | South Kīhei

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 4 | Wailea

• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 5 | Mākena

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 6 | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

• CPAC/Department Recommended Map (no changes)

Texts of Section 3.3 – 3.5

• Section 3.3 | Community Plan Map and Subareas_Text (Updated 6/21/23)
• Section 3.4 | Areas of Change_Text (Updated 6/21/23)
• Section 3.5 | Areas of Stability_Text

Additional Meeting Materials

• List of CPAC Changes to Growth Framework – Maps

Testimony

• Dean Frampton_Honua’ula/Wailea 670
• Lynn Britton_Subarea 1 (Mā‘alaea)
• Harry Lake_Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)
• Clarence Suda_Subarea 3 (South Kīhei)
• Calvert Chipcase_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Eduardo Gandolfo_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• William Spence_Subarea 5 (Mākena)

*All materials below were posted prior to the meeting’s cancellation.*

Meeting Materials

Honua’ula/Wailea 670 Growth Alternatives/Maps

• Original Department Recommended Map (August 2022)
• Updated Map (July 2023)

Review of Growth Alternatives/Maps

Subarea 1 | Mā‘alaea/Keālia

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 2 | North Kīhei

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 3 | South Kīhei

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 4 | Wailea

• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 5 | Mākena

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map (Updated as of July 13)

Subarea 6 | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

• CPAC/Department Recommended Map (no changes)

Texts of Section 3.3 – 3.5

• Section 3.3 | Community Plan Map and Subareas_Text (Updated 6/21/23)
• Section 3.4 | Areas of Change_Text (Updated 6/21/23)
• Section 3.5 | Areas of Stability_Text

Additional Meeting Materials

• List of CPAC Changes to Growth Framework – Maps

Testimony

• Dean Frampton_Honua’ula/Wailea 670 (Updated 7/17/23)
• Lynn Britton_Subarea 1 (Mā‘alaea)
• Harry Lake_Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)
• Mark Hyde_Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)
• Mark Hyde_Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)_Additional Testimony
• Clarence Suda_Subarea 3 (South Kīhei)
• Calvert Chipcase_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Eduardo Gandolfo_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Johann Lall_Subarea 4 (Wailea), Miscellaneous
  • Kilohana 1 | 2 | 3 | 4
  • Honua’ula 1 | 2 | South
  • Erosion Hazard Line
• William Spence_Subarea 5 (Mākena)
• David Goode_Section 3.5 Text

Meeting Materials

Honua’ula/Wailea 670 Maps with Updated Land Use Designations

• Original Department Recommended Map
• Updated Map

Review of CPAC Recommended Maps with Updated Land Use Designations

• List of CPAC Recommended Changes to Growth Framework/Maps

Subarea 1: Mā‘alaea/Keālia

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 2: North Kīhei

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 3: South Kīhei

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 4: Wailea (CPAC review in process)

• Department Recommended Map

Subarea 5: Mākena

• CPAC Recommended Map
• Updated Department Recommended Map

Subarea 6: ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

• CPAC/Department Recommended Map (no changes)

Text of Sections 3.3 – 3.5

• Section 3.3 Text (Updated 6/21/23)
• Section 3.4 Text (Updated 6/21/23)
• Section 3.5 Text

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Land use designation for TMK 390030160000 and 24 Kupuna Street_Subarea 3 (South Kīhei)
• Rob Weltman_Significant sites in South Maui_Other Committee Business – Temporarily unavailable

Testimony

*Please also refer to testimony in the July 12 and July 19 cancelled meeting tabs above*

• Harry & Jeanette Weinberg Foundation_Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)
• Clarence Suda_Subarea 3 (South Kīhei)
• Robb Cole_Subarea 5 (Mākena)

Subarea 1 (Mā‘alaea/Keālia) – In support of designating Mā‘alaea Mauka/Pohakea as Open Space

• Mā‘alaea Village Association
• Barbara Kozan
• Bill Lamkin
• Bobbie and Bill Best
• Brooke Etzel
• Carl Gann
• Carol Meynen
• Cheryl Goetz
• Christine Conlon Kemp
• Conde and Ann McGowan
• Danny Lisa
• Debra Davis
• Ed Clarke
• Frank Story
• Greg Hara
• Howard Dernehl
• Jan Arboit
• Jeanne Doty
• Jean Wilson
• John and Vicki Stewart
• John Urbanowski
• Jonah Goldberg
• Larry Stevens
• Leah Petrey
• Linda Freidenburg
• Linda Johansen
• Lora Harbo and David Liebersbach
• Mara Lockwood
• Mark Conley
• Mary Pedretti
• Mike and Priscilla Watson
• Nancy and John Norman
• Noboru Hara
• Paul Alkire
• Peter Cannon
• Richard and Ruby Kelley
• Rosemary DeGano
• Roz McKevitt
• Sharon Wright
• Steve Fucile
• Steven and Sue Tucker
• Steve Wendt
• Suellen Barton
• Susan Douglas
• Susan Frett
• Terri Zager
• Thomas Royer
• Tom Board
• Tony Alessandra
• Trey Page
• William Battles
• Yasmin Anderson
• Yolaine Stout
• John Starmer(Received after meeting)

Received at meeting

• Albert Perez_Subareas 1, 4, 5 (Mā‘alaea, Wailea, Mākena)

Received after testimony deadline

• Dana Naone Hall_Other Committee Business

Meeting Materials

Honua’ula/Wailea 670 Maps with Updated Land Use Designations

• Original Department Recommended Map
• Updated Map

Text of Sections 3.3 – 3.5

• Section 3.3 Text (Updated 6/21/23)
• Section 3.4 Text (Updated 6/21/23)
• Section 3.5 Text

Additional Materials

• Policy recommendations discussed at 8/30/2023 CPAC meeting

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Land use designation for TMK 390030160000 and 24 Kupuna Street_Subarea 3 (South Kīhei)
• Rob Weltman_Significant sites in South Maui_Other Committee Business – Temporarily unavailable

Testimony

*Please also refer to testimony in the July 12, July 19 and August 30 meeting tabs above*

• Isaac Hall_Subarea 5 (Mākena)

Meeting Materials

Text of Sections 3.4 – 3.5

• Section 3.4 | Areas of Change (Text only, updated 9/6/23)
• Section 3.5 | Areas of Stability (Text only)

Review and Recommendations: New Policy Language

• New Policy Language Requested by CPAC

Final Review of Policies

• CPAC Draft Section 2.1 – Policy Framework
• CPAC Draft Section 2.2 – Policy Framework
• CPAC Draft Section 2.3 – Policy Framework
• CPAC Draft Section 2.4 – Policy Framework
• CPAC Draft Section 2.5 – Policy Framework

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Outdated text in Section 3
• Daniel Kanahele_Member submission on section 3.4 and 3.5

Testimony

• Cal Chipcase_New Policy Language_Policies in Goals 2.4 and 2.5
• Randy Wagner_Policies related to Mauka North Kihei
• Kelly T. King_Other Committee Business

Testimony related to Text of Section 3.4 | Areas of Change (Mauka North Kīhei)

• Ada Zubiate-Owens
• Adele Rugg
• Andy Chenoweth
• Ania Wood
• Anna Enomoto
• Barbara Barry 1 | 2
• Bernadette Freitas
• Brandi Corpuz
• Carol Lee Kamekona
• Charlie Brissette
• Claudia Keane
• D. Austin
• Deborah Pozir
• Diane Shepherd
• Dick Mayer
• Gary Ahrnsbrak
• Heather Graf
• Jo Kimm
• Joanne L. Foxxe
• John Galert
• Kelly T. King
• Ken and Karen Stover
• Kim McEnaney
• Laura Gyori
• Linda Berry 1 | 2
• Madolin Wells
• Mele Stokesberry
• Milena Kari
• Patricia Nuckolls
• Rene Long
• Renee Richardson
• Sandy Brissette

Received at meeting

• David Goode_Section 3.5 Text
• Randy Wagner_Policies Related to Mauka North Kīhei
• Rory Frampton_Policies Related to Mauka North Kīhei

Received after testimony deadline

• Bruce E. Berger_Section 3.4 (Mauka North Kīhei)
• Jonathon Orlando_Section 3.4 (Mauka North Kīhei)
• Linda Duncan_Section 3.4 (Mauka North Kīhei)
• Lois Greenwood_Section 3.4 (Mauka North Kīhei)
• Leināʻala Vedder_Other Committee Business

Meeting Materials

Review and Recommendations: New Policy Language

• New Policy Language Requested by CPAC

Final Review of Policies

• CPAC Draft Section 2.1 – Policy Framework
• CPAC Draft Section 2.2 – Policy Framework
• CPAC Draft Section 2.3 – Policy Framework
• CPAC Draft Section 2.4 – Policy Framework
• CPAC Draft Section 2.5 – Policy Framework

Review and Recommendations: New Action Language

• New Action Language Requested by CPAC

Final Review of Actions

• CPAC Draft Section 4.4, Goal 2.1 – Implementation Schedule
• CPAC Draft Section 4.4, Goal 2.2 – Implementation Schedule
• CPAC Draft Section 4.4, Goal 2.3 – Implementation Schedule
• CPAC Draft Section 4.4, Goal 2.4 – Implementation Schedule
• CPAC Draft Section 4.4, Goal 2.5 – Implementation Schedule

CPAC Member Input

• Daniel Kanahele_Goal 2.1 – 2.4 Policies
• Daniel Kanahele_Member submission on Policies

Testimony

• Lucienne de Naie_Policies
• Randy Wagner_Transportation Actions
• Robin Knox_Other Committee Business
• Mā‘alaea Village Association_Other Committee Business

Received after testimony deadline

• Mallory Martin_New Policy Language, Section 2.1, Section 2.5

Meeting Materials

Final Review of Actions

• Goal 2.1 | A Complete, Balanced and Connected Transportation Network
• Goal 2.2 | Safe, Healthy, Livable Communities for All
• Goal 2.3 | Ready and Resilient Systems
• Goal 2.4 | Mauka to Makai Watershed Management
• Goal 2.5 | Responsible Stewardship of Wahi Kūpuna and Historic Properties

Review of CPAC Recommended Maps with Updated Land Use Designations

• List of CPAC recommended changes to Growth Framework/Maps
• Subarea 1 | Mā‘alaea/Keālia
• Subarea 2 | North Kīhei
• Subarea 3 | South Kīhei
• Subarea 4 | Wailea
• Subarea 5 | Mākena
• Subarea 6 | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

Final Review of Growth Framework

• Section 3.1 | Growth Framework
• Section 3.2 | Community Plan Designations
• Section 3.3 | Community Plan Map and Subareas
• Section 3.4 | Areas of Change
• Section 3.5 | Areas of Stability

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman_Typos in Draft Plan
• Rob Weltman_Input on Land Use Designations
• Brian Ward_Input on Actions and Land Use Designations
• Gary Passon_Input on Actions_Goal 2.2

Testimony

• Isaac Hall_Subarea 5 (Mākena)
• Larry Stevens_Other Committee Business

Review of CPAC Recommended Maps with Updated Land Use Designations (General)

• Bernard Lassalle
• Brett Gobar
• Eva Roberts
• Jo Kimm
• Joanne Foxxe
• Madolin Wells
• Nick Drance

Received at meeting

• Cal Chipcase_Subarea 4 (Wailea)
• Ka’imi Judd_Goal 2.5 Actions_Subarea 5 (Mākena)

Received after testimony deadline

• Allen Yap
• Bill Greenleaf
• Cheryl Hardt
• Debbi Brown
• Deborah Pozin
• Gylian Solay

Meeting Materials

Review of CPAC Recommended Maps with Updated Land Use Designations

• List of CPAC recommended changes to Growth Framework/Maps
• Subarea 1 | Mā‘alaea/Keālia
• Subarea 2 | North Kīhei
• Subarea 3 | South Kīhei
• Subarea 4 | Wailea
• Subarea 5 | Mākena
• Subarea 6 | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

Final Review of Growth Framework

• Section 3.1 | Growth Framework
• Section 3.2 | Community Plan Designations
• Section 3.3 | Community Plan Map and Subareas
• Section 3.4 | Areas of Change
• Section 3.5 | Areas of Stability

Review and Recommendations: New Policy Language

• New policy language from 10/4 CPAC meeting

Review and Recommendations: List of significant sites

• List of sites and areas from the 1998 Kihei-Makena Community Plan

Final Action Ranking

• Recommended ranking based on polling CPAC members

CPAC Member Input

• Rob Weltman – Significant sites in South Maui
• Gary Passon_Final Review of Policies

Testimony

• Rory Frampton-Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)
• Ka’onohi Lee_List of significant sites
• Ka’imi Judd_Subarea 5 (Mākena)
• Erin Mukai_Subarea 3 (South Kīhei)

Received at meeting

• Cal Chipcase_Section 3.4 (Areas of Change)
• Lucienne de Naie_List of significant sites
• Randy Wagner_Subarea 2 (North Kīhei)

Received after testimony deadline

• Carol-Lee Kamekona_Significant sites

Meeting Materials

*NOTE: This meeting also references CPAC member input and testimony from the October 11 recessed meeting.*

Review of CPAC Recommended Maps with Updated Land Use Designations

• List of CPAC recommended changes to Growth Framework/Maps
• Subarea 1 | Mā‘alaea/Keālia
• Subarea 2 | North Kīhei
• Subarea 3 | South Kīhei
• Subarea 4 | Wailea
• Subarea 5 | Mākena
• Subarea 6 | ‘Āhihi-Kīna’u/Kanaio

Final Review of Growth Framework

• Section 3.1 | Growth Framework
• Section 3.2 | Community Plan Designations
• Section 3.3 | Community Plan Map and Subareas
• Section 3.4 | Areas of Change
• Section 3.5 | Areas of Stability

Review and Recommendations: New Policy Language

• New policy language from 10/4 CPAC meeting

Review and Recommendations: List of significant sites

• List of sites and areas from the 1998 Kihei-Makena Community Plan

Final Action Ranking

• Recommended ranking based on polling CPAC members

Additional Meeting Material

• Actions not included in ranking

CPAC Member Input

• Lehuanani Huddleston-Hafoka – List of Significant Sites
• Rob Weltman-Mākena, Urban Growth Boundary
• Lehuanani Huddleston-Hafoka – New Policy Language, Gates

Testimony

• Kīhei Community Association – Subarea 2: North Kīhei
• Dick Mayer_Review of CPAC Recommended Maps
• Albert Perez_Subarea 2 (North Kihei)
• Lucienne de Naie_List of significant sites
• Lucienne de Naie_Clarifying maps for the 10.4.2023 request by Honua’ula Partners to amend fig 3.15

Meeting Materials

Review: Updated Draft South Maui Community Plan (October 2023)

• Section 1: Plan Framework
• Section 2: Policy Framework
• Section 3: Growth Framework
• Section 4: Implementation and Monitoring
• Section 5: Appendices

Testimony

• David Goode_Growth Framework
• Leināʻala Kuloloio Vedder_Significant sites
• N. Goode_Growth Framework

Received at meeting

• Randy Wagner_Growth Framework

Received after testimony deadline

• Ka’imi Judd_Growth Framework_Appendices

Meeting Materials

Review: Updated Draft South Maui Community Plan (October 2023)

• Section 1: Plan Framework
• Section 2: Policy Framework
• Section 3: Growth Framework
• Section 4: Implementation and Monitoring
• Section 5: Appendices

Updated Meeting Materials (October 20, 2023)

• Section 2: Pages Updated 10-18-2023 meeting
• Section 3: Pages Updated 10-18-2023 meeting
• Section 4: Pages Updated 10-18-2023 Meeting
• 10-18-2023 CPAC Changes to Growth Framework Maps

CPAC Member Input

• Brian Ward_Action Ranking

Testimony

*NOTE: This meeting also references testimony from the October 18 recessed meeting.*

• Colleen Curran_List of Significant Sites

Meeting Materials

Review: Updated Draft South Maui Community Plan (October 2023)

• Section 1: Plan Framework
• Section 2: Policy Framework
• Section 3: Growth Framework
• Section 4: Implementation and Monitoring
• Section 5: Appendices

Updated Meeting Materials

• Section 2: Pages Updated 10-18-2023 meeting
• Section 3: Pages Updated 10-18-2023 meeting
• Section 4: Pages Updated 10-18-2023 Meeting
• 10-23-2023 CPAC Changes to Growth Framework Maps
• Section 3: Pages Updated 10-23-2023 meeting

CPAC Member Input

• Daniel Kanahele_List of Significant Sites_Appendices

Testimony

*NOTE: This meeting also references testimony from the October 18 and 23 recessed meetings.*

• Ann Pitcaithley_Growth Framework_Significant Sites
• Anne A_Growth Framework_Significant Sites
• Audrey Lester Growth Framework
• Bonnie Newman Growth Framework
• Brandi Corpuz_Growth Framework_Significant Sites
• Dick Mayer_Growth Framework
• Lucienne de Naie Growth Framework, GPAC Maps
• Lucienne de Naie Significant Sites
• Lucienne de Naie Final Motion for Approval
• Michael Babineck_Growth Framework
• Paul Deslauriers Growth Framework
• Robin Knox Growth Framework
• Sean Lester Growth Framework
• Robin Knox Growth Framework
• Tracy Edelhertz_Appendices_Significant Sites

Received after testimony deadline

• Toni Eaton_Final Motion for Approval